Soy vs Paraffin Wax: Best for Pet Memorial Candles

August 9, 2024

Soy wax is generally the better choice for pet memorial candles:

Burns 30-50% longer than paraffin
Eco-friendly and biodegradable
Produces less soot and smoke
Safer for pets and people
Holds scents well for a clean, natural fragrance

Paraffin wax is cheaper and has a stronger initial scent, but has some drawbacks:

Burns faster
Petroleum-based and non-renewable
Produces more soot and potential toxins
Less safe around pets
Artificial scents can be overpowering

Quick Comparison:

Feature	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
Burn Time	30-50% longer	Shorter
Environmental Impact	Low	Higher
Scent Throw	Mild, long-lasting	Strong initially
Safety	Safer	Potential toxins
Cost	More expensive	Cheaper
Ease of Use	Good for beginners	Better for detailed designs

While paraffin has some advantages in cost and scent strength, soy wax is the recommended choice for a clean-burning, long-lasting, and pet-safe memorial candle.

Types of Wax

Pet memorial candles often use two main types of wax: soy wax and paraffin wax. Each has its own features that can affect your choice when making a candle for your pet.

What is Soy Wax?

Soy wax comes from soybean oil. Here's how it's made:

Farmers grow and pick soybeans
Machines press the beans to get oil
The oil is changed to make it solid

Soy wax is good for the earth because:

It breaks down naturally
More soybeans can be grown
It helps farmers in the USA

Soy wax melts at a lower heat than paraffin. This means:

The candle burns cooler
It might last longer
It makes less smoke

What is Paraffin Wax?

Paraffin wax comes from oil. Here's how it's made:

Oil is taken from the ground
The oil is cleaned to separate its parts
One part is turned into wax

Paraffin wax has been used for a long time, but it has some downsides:

It comes from oil, which can run out
It might release some bad stuff when it burns

People still like paraffin wax because:

It's cheaper
It holds smells well
It can be shaped into different designs

Here's a table that shows how soy and paraffin wax are different:

Feature	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
Where it comes from	Soybeans	Oil
Can it be replaced?	Yes	No
How long it burns	Longer	Shorter
How strong the smell is	Not as strong	Stronger
How much smoke it makes	Very little	More
Does it break down in nature?	Yes	No
How much it costs	More	Less

When you pick a wax for your pet's candle, think about how long you want it to burn, how strong you want the smell to be, and how it affects the earth. This can help you choose the best way to remember your pet.

How We Compare Waxes

We look at key factors when comparing soy and paraffin waxes for pet memorial candles. This helps pet owners choose the best wax for their needs.

What We Look At

We focus on these main areas:

1. Burn Quality

How much soot it makes
How clear it looks
If it frosts or gets spots

2. Scent

How strong the smell is at first
How long the smell lasts
How long it needs to set

3. Impact on Nature

Where it comes from
If it breaks down in nature
How much it affects the air

4. Safety

If it's toxic when burned
How it might affect health
If it's safe for pets

5. Practical Use

When it melts
How long it burns
What colors you can make
How easy it is to use at home

This table shows how soy and paraffin waxes are different:

Feature	Paraffin Wax	Soy Wax
Color with dye	Light to dark	Light colors
How it looks	A bit see-through	Not see-through
Soot	Black (depends on wick)	Almost no soot
Frosting	No frosting	Can frost
Smell strength	Strong right away	Takes 5-6 days to get strong
Where it's from	Oil by-product	Soybeans
Nature impact	Not good for nature	Better for nature
Melting point	Higher	Lower

This table helps you see the main differences between the two waxes at a glance.

Soy Wax for Pet Candles

Soy wax is becoming more common for pet memorial candles. Let's look at the good and bad points of using soy wax for these special candles.

Good Points of Soy Wax

Good Point	Explanation
Burns Clean	Makes very little soot, keeping the air clean when you remember your pet
Burns Longer	Lasts longer than other waxes, giving you more time to think about your pet
Good for Nature	Made from soybeans, which can be grown again and again
Safe	Not harmful, so it's okay to use around other pets and kids
Holds Smells Well	Keeps scents strong for a long time, which can be nice when using your pet's favorite smells

Bad Points of Soy Wax

Bad Point	Explanation
Soft	Not as hard as other waxes, so it might not work for all candle shapes
Melts Easily	Can melt if it's too warm, so you need to be careful where you put it
Can Look Spotty	Might get white spots on it, which doesn't hurt the candle but might not look as nice
Costs More	Usually more expensive than other waxes
Smell Takes Time	It might take a while for you to smell the scent when you first light the candle

When picking a soy wax candle to remember your pet, think about these good and bad points. Soy wax is clean and good for nature, which makes it a nice choice for honoring your pet while also being kind to the earth.

Paraffin Wax for Pet Candles

Paraffin wax is often used for making candles, including those for pets who have died. Let's look at the good and bad points of using paraffin wax for these special candles.

Good Points of Paraffin Wax

Good Point	What It Means
Costs less	Cheaper than other waxes, so you can make more candles
Strong smell	Holds and gives off scents well, good for pet-related smells
Easy to shape	Can be made into different shapes and sizes
Keeps color well	Stays bright for a long time
Burns for a long time	Lets you remember your pet for longer

Paraffin wax is good at holding smells, which is nice for pet candles. It's also cheap, so you can make many candles without spending too much money.

Bad Points of Paraffin Wax

Bad Point	What It Means
Not good for nature	Made from oil, which can't be replaced
Might not be safe	Can release bad stuff when it burns
Makes black smoke	Can leave marks on things nearby
Doesn't break down	Takes a long time to go away in nature
Needs more heat	Uses more energy to burn

Many pet owners worry about how paraffin wax affects nature. The smoke and possible bad stuff it releases when burning might also be a problem, especially if you have other pets or breathing issues.

When picking between paraffin and other waxes for your pet's candle, think about these good and bad points. While paraffin smells strong and costs less, it might not be the best choice if you care about nature or want something safer.

Soy vs Paraffin: Side-by-Side

Let's compare soy and paraffin wax for pet memorial candles. This will help you pick the best one for your needs.

Comparison Chart

Feature	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
What it's made from	Soybeans (can be regrown)	Oil (can't be regrown)
Effect on nature	Breaks down, good for earth	Doesn't break down, not good for earth
How long it burns	30-50% longer	Shorter
How strong it smells	Mild, takes time to smell	Strong, smells right away
Smoke it makes	Very little, clear	More, can be black
When it melts	At lower heat	At higher heat
Colors it can be	Light colors	Light or dark colors
How it looks	Not see-through	A bit see-through
Is it safe?	No bad stuff	Might have some bad stuff
How much it costs	More expensive	Cheaper

Soy wax is good for the earth and burns longer. It's made from soybeans, which farmers can grow again. Soy candles last 30-50% longer than paraffin ones. They also make very little smoke, which is clear and hard to see.

Paraffin wax costs less and is easy to find. It smells stronger, which is good if you like candles with a lot of scent. But paraffin candles might let out some bad stuff when they burn and make more smoke you can see.

For how they look, soy wax makes light colors and you can't see through it. Paraffin wax can be light or dark and you can kind of see through it. Soy wax melts at lower heat, which can be safer but might not work well in hot places.

When picking a wax for your pet's candle, think about what matters most to you. If you want something good for the earth, that burns longer, and makes less smoke, pick soy wax. If you want a stronger smell and don't mind about the earth stuff, paraffin wax might be better. Think about these things to pick the best wax to remember your pet.

Impact on the Environment

When picking between soy and paraffin wax for pet memorial candles, it's important to think about how they affect the earth. Let's look at how these two options impact our planet.

Soy Wax and the Environment

Soy wax has some good points for the earth:

Made from soybeans, which can be grown again
Breaks down in nature
Makes less pollution when made
Helps farmers grow more crops

But soy wax also has some problems:

Growing soybeans can lead to cutting down trees
Farmers often use bug sprays that can hurt nature
Many soybeans used are changed by scientists

Paraffin Wax and the Environment

Paraffin wax, which comes from oil, has some issues for the earth:

Made from oil, which will run out one day
Making it releases gases that warm the earth
Uses chemicals that can hurt water and land
Burning it can make the air inside homes dirty

How They Affect the Earth Over Time

Choosing soy or paraffin wax can change things for the earth in the long run:

What to Look At	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
Can we make more?	Yes	No
Does it break down?	Yes	No
How much it warms the earth	Less	More
How it affects air in homes	Not much	A lot
How it affects nature	Depends on how it's grown	Bad for nature

If more people use soy wax:

We might use less oil
Less gas that warms the earth
Cleaner air in homes
More farming (if done right)

If people keep using paraffin wax:

We'll use up more oil
More gas that warms the earth
More dirty air in homes
More harm to nature from getting and making oil

While soy wax is better for the earth overall, it's important to get it from good places and make it in ways that don't hurt nature.

Pet Safety

When choosing between soy and paraffin wax for pet memorial candles, it's important to think about how safe they are for pets. Let's look at each type of wax and how it might affect our animal friends.

Is Soy Wax Safe for Pets?

Soy wax is usually safer for pets than paraffin wax. Here's why:

It's not toxic
It burns at a lower heat
It makes very little smoke
It often uses natural smells

But pet owners should still be careful:

Eating a lot of soy wax can make pets sick
Some smells in soy candles might not be good for pets

Is Paraffin Wax Safe for Pets?

Paraffin wax can be more dangerous for pets:

It lets out bad stuff when it burns
It burns hotter, so it can hurt pets more if it spills
It makes more smoke that can be bad for pets to breathe

To keep pets safe when using candles:

Put candles where pets can't reach them
Don't leave burning candles alone
Make sure there's fresh air when burning candles
Watch pets for signs they might be sick
Ask a vet before using smelly candles around sick pets

Safety Issue	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
How bad it is if eaten	Not very	Worse
How hot it burns	Not as hot	Hotter
How much smoke it makes	Very little	More
Safe smells for pets	Often has them	Not as often

Scent and Fragrance

When picking between soy and paraffin wax for pet memorial candles, how they smell is very important. Let's look at how each wax type works with scents.

Which Wax Smells Stronger?

Here's how soy and paraffin wax compare when it comes to smell:

Feature	Paraffin Wax	Soy Wax
First smell	Strong, big	Soft, slow
How smell spreads	Fast	Even, steady
How true the smell is	Might change	Cleaner, more real
Time to smell good	Right away	5-6 days

Paraffin wax:

Melts at higher heat, so it gives off a strong smell fast
Can hold more scent oil, so it might smell stronger
Might change how the scent oil smells because it burns hot

Soy wax:

Melts at lower heat, making a bigger pool of wax that spreads smell well
Mixes well with scent oils, so the smell is cleaner and more real
Lets out smell slowly and evenly, so it's not as strong but lasts longer

Why Smell Matters in Memorial Candles

The smell of a memorial candle is important because:

It can bring back memories of your pet
It can help you feel better when you're sad
You can pick a smell that reminds you of your pet
It can make the room feel calm for thinking about your pet

When you pick a pet memorial candle, think about:

Choosing a smell that makes you think of your pet
Using smells that are safe for pets
Picking a smell that will last a long time

Burn Time and Quality

When picking between soy and paraffin wax for pet memorial candles, how long they burn and how they look matter. Let's see how these two waxes compare.

How Long Do They Burn?

Wax Type	Burn Time	Why
Soy Wax	30-50% longer	Melts at lower heat, denser
Paraffin Wax	Shorter	Melts at higher heat, less dense

Soy wax candles burn longer because:

They melt at lower heat
They have a denser structure
They melt and turn to gas more slowly

Paraffin wax candles don't last as long because:

They melt at higher heat
They have a less dense structure
They burn faster

How Do They Look When Burning?

Feature	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
Smoke	Very little, clear	More, black
How it burns	Even	Can be uneven
Flame	Steady, might be smaller	Bigger, might flicker
Melted wax	Big, even pool	Smaller pool, might make a tunnel

Soy wax candles:

Make very little smoke
Burn evenly
Have a steady flame
Make a big, even pool of melted wax

Paraffin wax candles:

Make more black smoke
Might burn unevenly
Have a bigger flame that might flicker
Can make a smaller pool of wax or burn down the middle

For pet memorial candles, soy wax might be better because it lasts longer and looks cleaner. But you can pick the one you like best based on how long you want it to burn and how you want it to look.

Price Comparison

Let's look at how much soy and paraffin wax cost for pet memorial candles. We'll also see which one gives you more for your money in the long run.

Which Wax Costs More?

Wax Type	Cost	Why It Costs This Much
Soy Wax	More	- Made from soybeans - Soybeans cost more
Paraffin Wax	Less	- Made from oil leftovers - Made in large amounts

Soy wax usually costs more than paraffin wax because it comes from soybeans. Paraffin wax is cheaper because it's made from oil leftovers. But prices can change based on where you buy it and how much you get.

Getting More for Your Money

When picking between soy and paraffin wax for pet memorial candles, think about:

Factor	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
How long it burns	30-50% longer	Not as long
Good for the earth	Yes	No
Clean burning	Yes	No
How strong it smells	Not as strong	Stronger
Can you reuse the container	Easier	Harder

Soy wax might cost more at first, but it can be worth it because:

It burns longer, so you don't need to buy as many candles
It's better for the earth
It burns cleaner, which is good for your home
You can clean and reuse the containers more easily

Paraffin wax is cheaper to buy, but it doesn't last as long and isn't as good for the earth or your home.

Making Custom Candles

Adding Personal Touches

You can make pet memorial candles more special by adding personal touches. Here are some ways to do this:

Personal Touch	Description
Photo Candles	Put a picture of your pet on the candle
Engraved Candles	Add your pet's name or dates to the candle holder
Memory Jar Candles	Make a layered candle with small items that remind you of your pet
Scented Candles	Use a smell that makes you think of your pet
Paw Print Design	Add a paw print to the top of the candle

These ideas work for both soy and paraffin wax candles.

Which Wax is Easier to Use?

Soy and paraffin wax have different features that affect how easy they are to use:

Feature	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
Melting Point	Lower (easier to use)	Higher (needs more heat)
Shaping	Good for simple designs	Better for detailed shapes
Smell Strength	Medium	Strong
Earth-Friendly	More	Less
Adding Color and Smell	Works well	Works very well

Soy wax is often easier for beginners because:

It melts at a lower heat
It's more forgiving if you make mistakes
It makes softer, more natural-looking candles

Paraffin wax can be harder to use but:

It's good for making detailed shapes
It makes candles look shiny
It holds smells better

When choosing between soy and paraffin wax for your pet's candle, think about:

How good you are at making candles
What kind of design you want
How strong you want the smell to be

Both types of wax can make nice candles to remember your pet.

What Experts Say

Candle Makers' Views

Most candle makers prefer soy wax for pet memorial candles. Here's why:

Reason	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
Cleanliness	Less smoke and bad stuff	More smoke
Burn time	30-50% longer	Shorter
Smell	Nicer, more natural	Stronger at first
Good for earth	Yes	No

Some candle makers still like paraffin wax because:

It smells strong right away
It costs less

Pet Memorial Experts' Thoughts

People who work with pet memorials often say soy wax is better:

1. Safety: It's not harmful, which is good if you have other pets

2. Meaning: It comes from plants, which feels nicer for remembering pets

3. Easy to use: You can make special designs more easily

Experts also talk about how candles smell:

What to look at	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
How long it smells	Smells for a long time	Smells strong at first, then fades
How nice it smells	More natural	Can smell fake
Safe for pets	Usually safer	Might have more fake smells

While some experts say paraffin is good for strong smells, most think soy wax is better overall for making safe and nice pet memorial candles.

Conclusion

Key Points to Remember

When picking between soy and paraffin wax for pet memorial candles, think about these things:

Feature	Soy Wax	Paraffin Wax
Earth-friendly	Yes, breaks down in nature	No, comes from oil
How long it burns	Longer	Shorter
How strong it smells	Smells good for a long time	Smells strong at first
How clean it burns	Makes less smoke	Makes more smoke
How much it costs	Costs more	Costs less
Safe for pets	Usually safer	Might not be as safe

What We Think is Best

We think soy wax is better for pet memorial candles. Here's why:

1. Good for the earth: Soy wax breaks down in nature and comes from plants that can be grown again.

2. Burns longer: Your candle will last longer, giving you more time to remember your pet.

3. Safe for pets: It makes less smoke and has fewer fake smells, which is good if you have other pets at home.

4. Smells nice: The smell lasts longer and seems more natural than paraffin wax.

5. Burns clean: It makes less black smoke, which is better for using inside your home.

Paraffin wax costs less and smells strong at first, but soy wax is better overall for making a nice, safe candle to remember your pet. In the end, pick what you like best and what matters most to you. But if you want something that's good for the earth, safe, and works well, soy wax is the best choice for honoring your pet's memory.

FAQs

Is paraffin wax or soy wax better for candles?

When picking between paraffin and soy wax for candles, think about what matters most to you:

Feature	Paraffin Wax	Soy Wax
Smell	Stronger smell right away	Good smell that lasts longer
How long it burns	Burns faster	Burns 30-50% longer
Good for the earth	Not as good, made from oil	Better, made from plants
Safe to use	Makes more smoke	Makes less smoke, safer to breathe

If you want a strong smell and don't mind about the earth, pick paraffin. But if you want a candle that:

Lasts longer
Is better for the earth
Is safer to use at home
Still smells nice

Then soy wax is the better choice. Most people think soy wax is better overall for making candles to remember pets.

Back to blog

Related video from YouTube